Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft Realms'
  1. Minecraft Realms
  2. REALMS-10040

Villagers and Minecarts (possibly other entities) are disappearing after Logging Out.

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • None
    • 1.18 (Bedrock)
    • None
    • We are using an XBOX
      Microsoft Realm Bedrock Edition was updated to 1.18.10 on the day the update was released

      downloading a backup of our realm, and will attach that when download is complete.
    • Community Consensus
    • Bedrock
    • 740272

      1.  Write a concise summary that clearly states the problem

      Villagers and Minecarts (possibly other entities) are disappearing after Logging Out.

      This problem has occurred since the 1.18.10 update, has happened with both newly created (since the update) and previous to update entities.  It seems to not ALWAYS occur with all entities, but randomly villagers / minecarts will disappear.
      We are playing on a Microsoft Realm, Minecraft Bedrock Edition, Survival mode, from the US and UK.
      this is NOT a Duplicate of MCPE-144208, as this issue, as confirmed by [MCPE Mod] AULDRICK:
      "This is the same set of symptoms as MCPE-144208, but it's not the same issue because it has a different cause." 

       

       

      2 A.  Precise steps to reproduce the issue. 
      EXACT/PRECISE conditions are unknown.
        2a-1.  Do not attempt to reproduce using your development environment.  X has already indicated you can not replicate in that environment
        2a-2. In a Production Environment (Mcdonalds wifi, external (non-Mojang) internet access) create (preferrabley with an XBox) a Realm for Minecraft, in Survival Mode, using any seed, or contact me for the specific Seed we use
        2a-3.  if using our seed, proceed to the village at X, Z (or nearest village if random seed).
        2a-4.  Build a library, 
           2a-4a making the interior spawn-proof for hostile mobs, 
           2a-4b ensure that Library is controlled access (double gate system, or scaffolding access only) 
        2a-5. begin to populate the library with librarians 
           2a-5a. create segmented areas with stone fencing, with 2 beds and 2 podiums per cubicle, but do this 1 librarian at a time
           2a-5b. work with each librarian (one at a time) to secure a different enchanted book at level one (put up podium, cut it down if not desired book), ensuring that Mending and Unbreaking are the first 2 books/librarians created.
           2a-5c Continue until 24 librarians are created, (can be 1 floor with 24 or 2 floors with 12 each floor as we created)
        2a-6.  Concurently, build 2 closed loop minecart systems
           2a.6a. each loop should contain a minimum of 40 rails, with at least 8 powered rails (using redstone blocks or torches) per loop
           2a.6b. each loop should have a hopper collection system as a part of it
           2a.6c. each loop should run with 1 hopper minecart
        2a-7. Save and Quit the realm upon completion, or even during the creation process if necessary (it can take some time to get the right books)
        2a-8.  Close out/power off the Xbox
        2a-9. return 8 - 12 hours later, powering on the Xbox, entering Minecraft, and joining the Realm created (again from an external internet access)
        2a-10.  Verify that all 24 Librarians are there.
           2a-10a If they are, then repeat steps 2a-6 thru 2a-9, preferably with a minimum of 1-2 hours of elapsed time between joining and leaving the realm.
           2a-10b If there are any missing, you have recreated the issue.
       
      2 B.  After listing the steps, clearly state what happens, and what you believe should happen.
         2a-10a is the desired result - all librarian villagers remain every time the realm is entered.

      3. Include the exact text of any messages 
          No error messages received

            Unassigned Unassigned
            MarriedInMinecraft Married In Minecraft
            Votes:
            19 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            20 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: