-
Bug
-
Resolution: Unresolved
-
None
-
1.21.60.21 Preview, 1.21.50.22 Preview, 1.21.40.25 Preview, 1.21.31 Hotfix
-
Unconfirmed
-
Multiple
In 1.21.30, the format_version of blocks.json is now used to find outdated block IDs used in the file. These outdated IDs appear as content errors in the Creator Content Log.
However, the content log messages are not always correct. There are both false positives and omissions.
For example, "terracotta" is counted as an outdated ID instead of "stained_hardened_clay". It should not be possible to have "outdated block ID" and "not in registry" errors for the same ID, but "terracotta" does:
False Positives
These block IDs throw errors when they shouldn't.
| Block ID | Notes |
|---|---|
| terracotta | This ID has never been used for a block on Bedrock Edition. It was included in the list instead of "stained_hardened_clay". |
Omissions
In addition, many changed IDs are missing from this error reporting. These block IDs should throw errors, but don't.
| Block ID | New Block IDs | Changed in... | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| concretePowder | black_concrete_powder blue_concrete_powder brown_concrete_powder cyan_concrete_powder gray_concrete_powder green_concrete_powder light_blue_concrete_powder light_gray_concrete_powder lime_concrete_powder magenta_concrete_powder orange_concrete_powder pink_concrete_powder purple_concrete_powder red_concrete_powder yellow_concrete_powder white_concrete_powder |
1.20.30 | The "concretePowder" ID was changed to "concrete_powder" in 1.18.30, but blocks.json still accepts concretePowder. |
| grass | grass_block | 1.21.0? | "grass_block" is never used in a vanilla blocks.json, but it is fully functional. Since this is the ID used in commands, it should also be the preferred ID in blocks.json. |
| invisibleBedrock | invisible_bedrock | 1.18.30 | |
| movingBlock | moving_block | 1.18.30 | |
| pistonArmCollision | piston_arm_collision | 1.18.30 | |
| seaLantern | sea_lantern | 1.18.30 | |
| stained_hardened_clay | black_terracotta blue_terracotta brown_terracotta cyan_terracotta gray_terracotta green_terracotta light_blue_terracotta light_gray_terracotta lime_terracotta magenta_terracotta orange_terracotta pink_terracotta purple_terracotta red_terracotta yellow_terracotta white_terracotta |
1.20.30 | This is the true unsplit ID for stained terracotta, instead of "terracotta". It does not throw any errors when used currently. |
| stickyPistonArmCollision | sticky_piston_arm_collision | 1.18.30 | |
| tripWire | trip_wire | 1.18.30 | |
| yellow_flower | dandelion | 1.21.20 |
Expected Result
All outdated block IDs throw errors when used in blocks.json with a format_version of 1.21.30 or later. False positives do not occur.
Observed Result
Some outdated block IDs still do not throw errors when used in blocks.json. False positives occur with the "terracotta" ID.
