While playing as a Player 2 on PS4 in Creepy Crypt, we got stuck in a dungeon. Trying to get out of it, I went to to leave the game real quick, hoping my character would re-spawn right next to Player 1 when I rejoined. However, when I rejoined the game, my existing character (level 38+) disappeared from my profile.

We tried restarting the game. We also tried starting the game using my profile, with me as Player 1. Both didn't restore my character.