Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-271646

Attribute Modifiers for Armor Enchantments Not Stackable Across Different Slots, Cluttering Item Descriptions

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Invalid
    • None
    • 24w18a
    • None
    • Unconfirmed
    • (Unassigned)

      Bug Overview:
      Armor enchantments utilizing attribute modifiers are unable to apply distinct UUID attribute modifiers based on the armor slot, preventing the stacking of effects when multiple armor pieces possess the enchantment. Additionally, there's an issue where the attribute modifier and its effects are displayed redundantly for each armor slot (head, body, legs, feet), cluttering the item description and presenting irrelevant information.

      Issue Details:
      Stacking Limitation: Currently, armor enchantments employing attribute modifiers do not distinguish between armor slots, causing the effects not to stack when multiple pieces with the same enchantment are equipped.
      Cluttered Item Descriptions: When hovering over an enchanted armor piece, the attribute modifier and its effects are redundantly displayed for all four armor slots (head, body, legs, feet), regardless of the actual slot the item occupies. This results in cluttered and irrelevant information, as the effects of a helmet enchantment, for instance, are inconsequential when the item is equipped on the feet slot.

      Impact:
      Gameplay Breakage: The inability to stack attribute modifier effects across different armor slots diminishes the effectiveness of certain enchantments, hindering gameplay strategies reliant on multiple enchanted pieces.
      User Experience Degradation: The cluttered item descriptions not only obscure relevant information but also diminish the overall user experience by presenting unnecessary details, disrupting player immersion.

      Reproduction Steps:
      Enchant multiple armor pieces with the same attribute-modifying enchantment.
      Equip the enchanted armor pieces across different armor slots.
      Observe that the effects of the enchantment do not stack.
      Hover over any equipped enchanted armor piece to witness redundant attribute modifier descriptions for all armor slots.

      Expected Behavior: Attribute modifiers for armor enchantments should allow distinct UUID attribute modifiers depending on the armor slot, enabling the stacking of effects when multiple pieces possess the enchantment. Additionally, item descriptions should only display attribute modifier information relevant to the equipped armor slot, avoiding clutter and presenting concise information.

      Proposed Solution:
      Introduce a mechanism for armor enchantments to utilize distinct UUID attribute modifiers based on the equipped armor slot, enabling the stacking of effects.
      Revise the item description mechanism to display attribute modifier information relevant to the equipped armor slot, reducing clutter and improving user experience.

            Unassigned Unassigned
            Xanbelor Xanbelor
            Votes:
            1 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            0 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: