Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-137154

Structure blocks when loading pop off some comparators [1.13.1 java win7]



    • Bug
    • Status: Resolved
    • Resolution: Duplicate
    • Minecraft 1.13.1
    • None
    • None
    • Windows 7, latest Java update.
    • Unconfirmed


      To be clear when I say "pops off" I mean that where the comparator is supposed to be attached within its block space it is not attached and a floating comparator ITEM is left floating in its place [which will despawn after the regular time].
      I spend a lot of time on my realm doing redstone stuff and since the 1.13 change I have not been able to use my WorldEdit mod so I have been using the structure blocks for copy, paste, and rotation a lot so I can combine large sections of redstone machines so that they work together and this is a constant persistent issue, especially when I have to replace comparators in tucked in spaces you just can't get to, where I have at times resorted to using chat commands to place them because it is actually faster than a partial breakdown and rebuild.

      I had not noticed any real pattern to how it pops off comparators as it will pop off some while others are fine. It can properly place a whole row of them and pop off other specific ones or sometimes pop off a whole row and leave other specific ones. It is common as it happens all the time and it is only sometimes that it properly places all of them. Keep in mind that I typically have a large number of comparators in my redstone contraptions [like classic item sorters to even more complex cart type sorters], so this may be an indicator as to why it happens to me so much since I do so much redstone. It does not seem to do this with repeaters or other types of redstone [that I have noticed], it seems to be just the comparators. I am not sure how to get structure files from my realm since that is where all my work is and there is no file browser, otherwise I would have attached some of them.

      I originally came here to see if the bug is being worked on as this has been happening for a while now and I expected to see a report but I am guessing not too many people are using the structure blocks, especially in this way since I just found this one: https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-134637 which shows it as resolved but that is apparently on windows 10 which is apparently somehow different on that OS ['better together'?], and this problem is in reference to the java edition on windows 7 and I have the latest update 1.13.1 and this is still continually happening. After seeing this other bug report I cannot be certain if it only happens on slabs and never on solids as I had not noticed, but I can assure you in win 7 java edition 1.13.1 it is NOT RESOLVED [as of 2018-10-01].



        Issue Links



              Unassigned Unassigned
              jill_kitten@yahoo.com Jill Kitten
              0 Vote for this issue
              1 Start watching this issue