[MC-834] Mushroom stew makes wrong sounds when eaten Created: 27/Oct/12  Updated: 03/Dec/20  Resolved: 09/Nov/12

Status: Resolved
Project: Minecraft: Java Edition
Component/s: None
Affects Version/s: Minecraft 1.4.2
Fix Version/s: None

Type: Bug
Reporter: Simons Mith Assignee: Unassigned
Resolution: Invalid Votes: 25
Labels: mushroom, sound, stew
Environment:

Mac OS 10.6.8, iMac, 3GB RAM


Issue Links:
Duplicate
is duplicated by MC-15640 Soup Sound Bug Resolved
is duplicated by MC-3519 Mushroom stev has eat sound instead o... Resolved
Confirmation Status: Unconfirmed
Game Mode: Survival

 Description   

When you eat mushroom stew, you get the eating sounds and particles rather than the drinking sounds (and no particles), and the latter would be more appropriate.



 Comments   
Comment by Testing [ 03/Dec/20 ]

You meant, to fix when soup can now make a drink sound with no particle sound instead of eating sound with particle?

Comment by ANBO Motohiko [ 01/Feb/13 ]

This should be marked as 'Work as intended', not 'invalid'.

Comment by Simons Mith [ 10/Nov/12 ]

Correction, not the wiki. I don't think there's anything even vaguely request-related left on the wiki now.

Comment by Cloudy (Aaron Mills) [ 09/Nov/12 ]

Stew is food. Food is eaten. Hence the eating animation.

This is a request to change that behaviour to something you feel makes more sense. That's fine - you're entitled to make requests in the right locations (e.g. the forums or the wiki) - however, this is NOT a bug.

Comment by Simons Mith [ 09/Nov/12 ]

Why has this bug been marked 'invalid'? Please can I have a definition of 'feature request'?

AFAICS, this fits the definition of a bug, in this case it's a type 1 bug from the wiki definition, 'The computer is doing something it shouldn't do.' An incorrect animation plus sound effects are playing. They are incorrect because they falsely give the impression that you are eating both the stew /and/ the bowl, which is not what you'd expect. Using the drinking SFX and the drinking animation would not give this impression. As code for drinking SFX and a drinking animation are available in the game it would be more appropriate to use them. /Only if they did not exist/ would asking for drinking SFX and a drinking animation for stew be a request for a new feature.

If you are going to close this bug, it should be marked either as 'Won't Fix', which means something like 'Yes, the animation isn't really right, but we're not going to worry too much about correcting it,' or 'Works as intended,' which I would take to mean to 'The animation may not quite be correct, but we are sticking to the principle that all food uses the eating animation, and only potion consumption uses the drinking animation'. Using 'invalid' as a dumping classification for every bug that doesn't quite satisfy the /currently unknown/ criteria used by the mods here is inaccurate and somewhat unfair.

Comment by Fisico [ 29/Oct/12 ]

i think this is a bug cause this is looking really weird you eat the stew + bowl

Comment by [Mod] CubeTheThird [ 27/Oct/12 ]

This is not a bug, but rather a feature request, and should be posted on the minecraft forums.

Generated at Sun Jan 12 11:52:23 UTC 2025 using Jira 9.12.2#9120002-sha1:301bf498dd45d800842af0b84230f1bb58606c13.