XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Cannot Reproduce
    • None
    • 1.9.0
    • None
    • Unconfirmed
    • Windows

      This appears to be fixed in 1.10. Though seeing as I haven't found the change log with this fix mentioned, I'll leave it up temporarily.

      From the changelog:

      • Player position is now accurately saved when exiting and rejoining a world

      Description:

      When signing out of a game at world height (standing on a block at y= 255, player height = 256), signing back in to the game results in a variety of unpredictable behaviors.

      The most frequent possibility is that the player will appear somewhere below the block they signed out on, slightly offset in x or z coordinate value (this is not what is described in https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-38374).

      The next most common result is respawning in at y = -40 (below bedrock) and instantly dying if in survival.

      The least common behavior is actually respawning where you signed off, which would be the expected result.

      Steps to Reproduce:

      1) Create a new creative world.

      2) Place a block at y=255 and stand in the middle of it.

      3) Leave the game and come back.

      4) Notice the variety of strange results.

      5) For more fun, fill a 16x16 area around the player's perch down to y=2 with solid blocks. Move around and retry. Certain positions seemed more likely to result in strange behavior than others.

      Severity:

      Moderately severe by my estimate. While it's unlikely that most players build to world height, those that do can encounter severe progress loss. It also indicates a slightly unpredictable implementation, which could indicate further issues not yet discovered.

      Unlisted Video Example (7:27): https://youtu.be/r8Ups0My1uw

      The end of the video contains two below bedrock spawns, and they can occur even with air blocks below the block(s) at 255.

        1. Test 2 Setup.png
          Test 2 Setup.png
          198 kB
        2. Test 2 Result.png
          Test 2 Result.png
          894 kB
        3. Test 1 Result.png
          Test 1 Result.png
          1.48 MB
        4. Test 1 Setup.png
          Test 1 Setup.png
          2.75 MB
        5. Broken Respawn.mcworld
          1.74 MB

            GMOHeaven GMO Heaven
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: