Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft (Bedrock codebase)'
  1. Minecraft (Bedrock codebase)
  2. MCPE-120078

Exiting rideable (minecart, boat) places player in unsafe location (water, lava, inside blocks), and minecarts can no longer drop mobs into holes


    • Confirmed
    • Multiple
    • 485744, 486441

      The change "Added new logic for mobs dismounting rideable" breaks the minecart logic and boat exiting.

      The following issues occur:

      • A player in a minecart going over an activator rail with solid blocks at a head height will suffocate, because the minecart prefers to put the player inside of solid blocks instead of on trapdoors, water, or a safe fall next to the track (see Mine cart Murders me.mcworld ).
      • Minecarts going over activator rails no longer drop mobs into holes, ruining many mob farms and villager transport systems.
      • It doesn't fix the issue with the boat, as you fall through when you get in water. Fall through boat.mp4 (MCPE-105535)
      • It doesn't fix the issue on the strider on going into lava.

      I am unclear on what this actually fixes as the stated fixes are not actually not fixed and the the player/entities end up often put into more hazardous locations IE inside of blocks causing suffocation damage.

      This is a regression that actually causes death in more condition then it prevents.

      Workaround by Auldrick:

      See this comment for information on how to work around this problem.

        1. Activator Rail Workaround.mcworld
          607 kB
        2. Big ups.mp4
          7.84 MB
        3. Fall through boat.mp4
          9.04 MB
        4. IMG_7547.jpg
          104 kB
        5. IMG_7547 1.jpg
          IMG_7547 1.jpg
          26 kB
        6. Jump around.mp4
          4.89 MB
        7. Mine cart Murders me.mcworld
          88 kB
        8. Minecraft 11_23_2021 4_12_51 PM.png
          Minecraft 11_23_2021 4_12_51 PM.png
          694 kB
        9. Minecraft 2021.03.18 -
          8.86 MB
        10. No port or starboard exit.mp4
          1.85 MB
        11. Strider fire.mp4
          1.03 MB
        12. Up you go.mp4
          5.09 MB

            ravinmaddhatter MadHatter
            54 Vote for this issue
            24 Start watching this issue