Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-268893

Comparators require a block update to function properly, and droppers/observers receive false state changes

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • 24w13a
    • 24w09a
    • None
    • Community Consensus
    • Redstone
    • Very Important
    • Platform

      On the most recent snapshot, redstone comparators run into an issue when reading the signal from a container with items, particularly from a dispensed shulker box. In the screenshot with the copper bulbs, the observer should read an update from the comparator because the shulker box in front of it is filled with items. However, the comparator does not turn on until it receives a block update from the copper bulb simply being placed behind it.

      Similarly, this causes issues with the shulker box loader design I use. The dropper on the left is powered by QC from the top comparator while the shulker box is in the dispenser. Then, when the dispenser places the shulker box, the dropper is powered by the comparator below it. This means that the dropper on the left side of the shulker box loader is always triggered, however the observer takes a reading from the dropper as if it's state has changed. 2 other images to illustrate this change are provided. The copper bulb should not change state because the dropper is always powered (tested using the 'tick step function') but for some reason the observer sees an update in the dropper's state and changes the state of the copper bulb.

      Let me know if there's anything else I can provide, this is my first ever bug report! This could be an intended change to block update order or something, but it seems like a bug to me at first glance, and I saw nothing in the snapshot notes to reflect this change. This does not seem directional.

        1. 2024-02-29_11.03.58.png
          2024-02-29_11.03.58.png
          477 kB
        2. 2024-02-28_20.01.24.png
          2024-02-28_20.01.24.png
          1.37 MB
        3. 2024-02-28_20.01.18.png
          2024-02-28_20.01.18.png
          1.28 MB
        4. 2024-02-28_19.56.42.png
          2024-02-28_19.56.42.png
          900 kB
        5. 2024-02-28_19.56.34.png
          2024-02-28_19.56.34.png
          972 kB
        6. 2024-02-28_19.53.06.png
          2024-02-28_19.53.06.png
          832 kB
        7. 2024-02-28_13.54.59.png
          2024-02-28_13.54.59.png
          985 kB

            panda4994 [Mojang] Panda
            DopeAnteater DopeAnteater
            Votes:
            3 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:
              CHK: