Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-258689

Wall signs, torches and skulls/heads no longer use wall variant translation keys since 18w02a

XMLWordPrintable

    • Confirmed
    • Text
    • Low
    • Gameplay

      Between 17w47a and 18w01a (inclusive), wall signs, torches and skulls/heads used the translation key "block.minecraft.<wall id>", now they use "block.minecraft.<standing id>".

      Steps to reproduce:
      Replace <standing id> and <wall id> with the values matching the below table.

      1. /give @s minecraft:diamond_axe[minecraft:can_break={blocks:["minecraft:oak_sign","minecraft:oak_wall_sign"]}]
      2. Observe how the 2 match.
      3. /tellraw @s [{"translate":"block.minecraft.<standing id>"},"\n",{"translate":"block.minecraft.<wall id>"}]
      4. Observe how a different string is printed for the wall block.
      Block Standing ID Wall ID
      Oak Sign oak_sign oak_wall_sign
      Spruce Sign spruce_sign spruce_wall_sign
      Birch Sign birch_sign birch_wall_sign
      Jungle Sign jungle_sign jungle_wall_sign
      Acacia Sign acacia_sign acacia_wall_sign
      Dark Oak Sign dark_oak_sign dark_oak_wall_sign
      Mangrove Sign mangrove_sign mangrove_wall_sign
      Cherry Sign cherry_sign cherry_wall_sign
      Bamboo Sign bamboo_sign bamboo_wall_sign
      Crimson Sign crimson_sign crimson_wall_sign
      Warped Sign warped_sign warped_wall_sign
      Oak Hanging Sign oak_hanging_sign oak_wall_hanging_sign
      Spruce Hanging Sign spruce_hanging_sign spruce_wall_hanging_sign
      Birch Hanging Sign birch_hanging_sign birch_wall_hanging_sign
      Jungle Hanging Sign jungle_hanging_sign jungle_wall_hanging_sign
      Acacia Hanging Sign acacia_hanging_sign acacia_wall_hanging_sign
      Dark Oak Hanging Sign dark_oak_hanging_sign dark_oak_wall_hanging_sign
      Mangrove Hanging Sign mangrove_hanging_sign mangrove_wall_hanging_sign
      Cherry Hanging Sign cherry_hanging_sign cherry_wall_hanging_sign
      Bamboo Hanging Sign bamboo_hanging_sign bamboo_wall_hanging_sign
      Crimson Hanging Sign crimson_hanging_sign crimson_wall_hanging_sign
      Warped Hanging Sign warped_hanging_sign warped_wall_hanging_sign
      Torch torch wall_torch
      Redstone Torch redstone_torch redstone_wall_torch
      Soul Torch soul_torch soul_wall_torch
      Skeleton Skull skeleton_skull skeleton_wall_skull
      Wither Skeleton Skull wither_skeleton_skull wither_skeleton_wall_skull
      Player Head player_head player_wall_head
      Zombie Head zombie_head zombie_wall_head
      Creeper Head creeper_head creeper_wall_head
      Piglin Head piglin_head piglin_wall_head
      Dragon Head dragon_head dragon_wall_head

      This also affects wall banners, but those are tracked in MC-124142 and are missing their wall variant translation keys, unlike these blocks.

      Unaffected blocks:

      • Tube Coral Wall Fan
      • Brain Coral Wall Fan
      • Bubble Coral Wall Fan
      • Fire Coral Wall Fan
      • Horn Coral Wall Fan
      • Dead Tube Coral Wall Fan
      • Dead Brain Coral Wall Fan
      • Dead Bubble Coral Wall Fan
      • Dead Fire Coral Wall Fan
      • Dead Horn Coral Wall Fan

            Unassigned Unassigned
            zTxrbq [Mod] turbo
            Votes:
            10 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            9 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              CHK: