Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-252262

Ancient city structures are inconsistently named

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Invalid
    • None
    • 1.19 Pre-release 3, 1.19 Pre-release 4, 1.19, 1.19.2
    • None
    • Confirmed
    • Structures

      The Bug:

      Ancient city structures are inconsistently named.

      Throughout the game, the names of some ancient city structures contain an underscore followed by a number at the end of them, and some of them don't, therefore introducing an inconsistency. Even when there's only one type of structure, "_1" should be present at the end of the structure's name. For example, the structure "sauna_1" correctly utilizes this concept and other structures such as "small_statue" don't.

      Below is a table I've constructed that shows all of the naming inconsistencies within ancient city structures.

      Affected Names:

      Before reading the table, please note the following:

      • Words colored in GREEN are correct.
      • Words colored in RED are incorrect.

       

      Current Structure Name Expected Structure Name
      minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_connector minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_connector_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_1 minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_2 minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_3 minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_3
      minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_4 minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_4
      minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_5 minecraft:ancient_city/city/entrance/entrance_path_5
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/city_center_1 minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/city_center_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/city_center_2 minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/city_center_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/city_center_3 minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/city_center_3
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_1 minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_2 minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_left_corner minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_left_corner_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_right_corner minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_right_corner_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_right_corner_1 minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_right_corner_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_right_corner_2 minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/bottom_right_corner_3
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/left minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/left_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/right minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/right_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/top minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/top_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/top_left_corner minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/top_left_corner_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/top_right_corner minecraft:ancient_city/city_center/walls/top_right_corner_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/barracks minecraft:ancient_city/structures/barracks_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/camp_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/camp_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/camp_2 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/camp_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/camp_3 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/camp_3
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/chamber_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/chamber_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/chamber_2 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/chamber_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/chamber_3 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/chamber_3
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/ice_box_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/ice_box_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/large_pillar_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/large_pillar_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/large_ruin_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/large_ruin_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/medium_pillar_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/medium_pillar_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/medium_ruin_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/medium_ruin_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/medium_ruin_2 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/medium_ruin_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/sauna_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/sauna_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/small_ruin_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/small_ruin_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/small_ruin_2 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/small_ruin_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/small_statue minecraft:ancient_city/structures/small_statue_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/tall_ruin_1 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/tall_ruin_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/tall_ruin_2 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/tall_ruin_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/tall_ruin_3 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/tall_ruin_3
      minecraft:ancient_city/structures/tall_ruin_4 minecraft:ancient_city/structures/tall_ruin_4
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_corner_wall_1 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_corner_wall_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_1 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_2 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_bridge minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_bridge_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_passage_1 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_passage_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_stairs_1 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_stairs_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_stairs_2 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_stairs_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_stairs_3 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_stairs_3
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_stairs_4 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_horizontal_wall_stairs_4
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_intersection_wall_1 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_intersection_wall_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_lshape_wall_1 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/intact_lshape_wall_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_corner_wall_1 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_corner_wall_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_corner_wall_2 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_corner_wall_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_horizontal_wall_stairs_1 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_horizontal_wall_stairs_1
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_horizontal_wall_stairs_2 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_horizontal_wall_stairs_2
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_horizontal_wall_stairs_3 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_horizontal_wall_stairs_3
      minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_horizontal_wall_stairs_4 minecraft:ancient_city/walls/ruined_horizontal_wall_stairs_4

      Steps to Reproduce:

      • Locate any of the structure names listed above and compare them with other structure names.
      • Take note as to whether or not ancient city structures are inconsistently named.

      Observed Behavior:

      Ancient city structures are inconsistently named.

      Expected Behavior:

      All ancient city structure names would contain an underscore followed by a number at the end of them to maintain consistency with one another.

            Unassigned Unassigned
            Avoma [Mod] Avoma
            Votes:
            5 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:
              CHK: