Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-140503

Cannot create Super Villages on Superflat in 1.13 or higher

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Duplicate
    • None
    • Minecraft 1.13.2
    • None
    • Unconfirmed

      In Minecraft 1.12 & lower, you can create massive villages in Superflat by setting the distance to 9 & the size to 100 in presets. In 1.13 & higher, no amount of messing with the size & distance will get the villages anywhere near close enough.

      Additionally, trying to create a super village on Superflat with a snow top layer & dark oak saplings in either version will fail to generate & crash.

      In a very old Reddit post for Beta 1.4.2, Dinnerbone explained why the minimum distance was switched from 0 to 9. But in latter versions, the village generation was not as close-compact as his screencaps.  

      https://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/12lzxj/i_buffed_the_village_size_to_almost_infinite/

      The village distance on the same settings increased heavily between Beta & 1.12 & then exponentially by 1.13.

      Superflat generators like the one below, last updated in April 2018 according to Archive.org, give out codes for different versions of Minecraft. Either the preset code for villages has changed enough from 1.13 snapshot 18w14b to make the generator partly useless, or the 1.13+ villages are just loading further apart.

      http://minecraft.tools/en/flat.php

      I have also tried with without the layer of jungle saplings & get the same results.

      This is potentially a side effect of MC-140238, where villages don't seem to spawn at all in Superflat, because I had to tweak the size & distance of villages just to get them to appear as close as they were, & on 9/10 tries in failing to create a supervillage on 1.13 & 1.13.2, no village appeared whatsover.

        1. 9 -1.13 Super Village Failed.PNG
          9 -1.13 Super Village Failed.PNG
          930 kB
        2. 8 - 1.13 Code.PNG
          8 - 1.13 Code.PNG
          47 kB
        3. 7 1.13 Code.PNG
          7 1.13 Code.PNG
          21 kB
        4. 6 Snow Villages Can't Generate.PNG
          6 Snow Villages Can't Generate.PNG
          35 kB
        5. 5 - 1.13.2 Super Village Failed.PNG
          5 - 1.13.2 Super Village Failed.PNG
          1.13 MB
        6. 4 - 1.13.2 Custom Preset.PNG
          4 - 1.13.2 Custom Preset.PNG
          39 kB
        7. 3 - 1.12 Super Village Achieved.PNG
          3 - 1.12 Super Village Achieved.PNG
          1.58 MB
        8. 2 - 1.12 Custom Preset.PNG
          2 - 1.12 Custom Preset.PNG
          50 kB
        9. 1 Superflat Generator Codes.PNG
          1 Superflat Generator Codes.PNG
          100 kB

            Unassigned Unassigned
            likalaruku Allaiyah Weyn
            Votes:
            2 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: