Minecraft
  1. Minecraft
  2. MC-109577

Unbreaking and Mending are only listed in Tools creative inventory tab

    Details

    • Confirmation Status:
      Confirmed

      Description

      The bug

      Based on the fix for MC-107550 items can now be in multiple creative inventory tabs. Because of this, I would expect Unbreaking and Mending to be in the Combat tab as well.

        Activity

        Hide
        Melvin Schop added a comment -

        Well this seemed unusual to have items appear in multiple tabs, but at the very least make it consistent:

        A list with highly recommended Tab changes/additions:

        Affected Item Add to Creative Tab Remove from Creative Tab Reason
        Spider Eye Brewing - Mostly used for brewing
        Pufferfish Brewing - Mostly used for brewing
        Nether Wart Brewing - Mostly used for brewing
        Chorus Fruit Food - Can be eaten
        Golden Carrot Food - Can be eaten
        Cauldron Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace
        Brewing Stand Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace
        Fireworks Star - Miscellaneous useless item (if you want to hint new players that this item exists, add a template firework?)
        Slimeball Materials Miscellaneous Used in multiple crafting recipes
        Book Materials Miscellaneous Used in multiple crafting recipes
        Paper Materials Miscellaneous Used in multiple crafting recipes
        Bone Materials Miscellaneous Used in crafting recipe
        Snowball Materials Miscellaneous Used in crafting recipe
        Ender Pearl Materials Miscellaneous Used in crafting recipe
        Ender Eye Materials Miscellaneous Used in crafting recipe
        Beacon Decorative Blocks Miscellaneous Utility block like furnace
        Detector Rail Redstone - Directly activates redstone
        Activator Rail Redstone - Gets directly activated by redstone
        Powered Rail Redstone - Gets directly activated by redstone
        Dispenser Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace
        Dropper Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace
        Trapped Chest Decorative Blocks - Utility block like chest
        Noteblock Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace
        Redstone Lamp Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        End Crystal Miscellaneous Decorative Blocks Entity, not a block
        Armor Stand Miscellaneous Decorative Blocks Entity, not a block
        Item Frame Miscellaneous Decorative Blocks Entity, not a block
        Painting Miscellaneous Decorative Blocks Entity, not a block
        Pumpkin Seeds Miscellaneous Materials Can't be used in crafting recipes
        Melon Seeds Miscellaneous Materials Can't be used in crafting recipes
        Wheat Seeds Miscellaneous Materials Can't be used in crafting recipes
        Beetroot Seeds Miscellaneous Materials Can't be used in crafting recipes
        Ghast Tear Materials - Also used in end crystal recipe
        Iron Horse Armor Transportation Miscellaneous Used only on horses which are transportation
        Gold Horse Armor Transportation Miscellaneous Used only on horses which are transportation
        Diamond Horse Armor Transportation Miscellaneous Used only on horses which are transportation
        Oak Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Spruce Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Birch Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Jungle Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Acacia Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Dark Oak Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Iron Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Wooden Trapdoor Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Iron Trapdoor Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Oak Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Spruce Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Birch Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Jungle Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Acacia Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Dark Oak Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative
        Slimeblock Redstone - Used alongside sticky pistons (redstone people will also be very happy to not switch tabs to get this)
        Wither Skeleton Skull Materials - Used in various crafting recipes
        Creeper Head Materials - Used in various crafting recipes
        Coal Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
        Iron Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
        Gold Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
        Diamond Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
        Redstone Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
        Emerald Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
        Lapis Lazuli Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
        Quartz Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
        Jack o' Lantern Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Used mostly for lighting, decoration (also remove the requirement for a block below to be present to be able to place, highly annoying)
        Book Case Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Mostly used for decoration
        Coal Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative
        Iron Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative
        Diamond Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative
        Gold Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative
        Emerald Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative
        Lapis Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative
        (Wet) Sponge Block Miscellaneous and/or Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Who builds with these... really?

        Take a close look at the table below and decide which to change, hopefully most of them because they make sense, some of the bottom few are possibly more optional, but especially most of the top ones are highly recommended to change. It is sometimes a hassle to find an item quickly because of this. Most of the times, the search function is preferred cause of this.

        Show
        Melvin Schop added a comment - Well this seemed unusual to have items appear in multiple tabs, but at the very least make it consistent: A list with highly recommended Tab changes/additions: Affected Item Add to Creative Tab Remove from Creative Tab Reason Spider Eye Brewing - Mostly used for brewing Pufferfish Brewing - Mostly used for brewing Nether Wart Brewing - Mostly used for brewing Chorus Fruit Food - Can be eaten Golden Carrot Food - Can be eaten Cauldron Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace Brewing Stand Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace Fireworks Star - Miscellaneous useless item (if you want to hint new players that this item exists, add a template firework?) Slimeball Materials Miscellaneous Used in multiple crafting recipes Book Materials Miscellaneous Used in multiple crafting recipes Paper Materials Miscellaneous Used in multiple crafting recipes Bone Materials Miscellaneous Used in crafting recipe Snowball Materials Miscellaneous Used in crafting recipe Ender Pearl Materials Miscellaneous Used in crafting recipe Ender Eye Materials Miscellaneous Used in crafting recipe Beacon Decorative Blocks Miscellaneous Utility block like furnace Detector Rail Redstone - Directly activates redstone Activator Rail Redstone - Gets directly activated by redstone Powered Rail Redstone - Gets directly activated by redstone Dispenser Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace Dropper Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace Trapped Chest Decorative Blocks - Utility block like chest Noteblock Decorative Blocks - Utility block like furnace Redstone Lamp Decorative Blocks - Decorative End Crystal Miscellaneous Decorative Blocks Entity, not a block Armor Stand Miscellaneous Decorative Blocks Entity, not a block Item Frame Miscellaneous Decorative Blocks Entity, not a block Painting Miscellaneous Decorative Blocks Entity, not a block Pumpkin Seeds Miscellaneous Materials Can't be used in crafting recipes Melon Seeds Miscellaneous Materials Can't be used in crafting recipes Wheat Seeds Miscellaneous Materials Can't be used in crafting recipes Beetroot Seeds Miscellaneous Materials Can't be used in crafting recipes Ghast Tear Materials - Also used in end crystal recipe Iron Horse Armor Transportation Miscellaneous Used only on horses which are transportation Gold Horse Armor Transportation Miscellaneous Used only on horses which are transportation Diamond Horse Armor Transportation Miscellaneous Used only on horses which are transportation Oak Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative Spruce Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative Birch Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative Jungle Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative Acacia Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative Dark Oak Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative Iron Door Decorative Blocks - Decorative Wooden Trapdoor Decorative Blocks - Decorative Iron Trapdoor Decorative Blocks - Decorative Oak Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative Spruce Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative Birch Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative Jungle Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative Acacia Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative Dark Oak Fence Gate Decorative Blocks - Decorative Slimeblock Redstone - Used alongside sticky pistons (redstone people will also be very happy to not switch tabs to get this) Wither Skeleton Skull Materials - Used in various crafting recipes Creeper Head Materials - Used in various crafting recipes Coal Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative Iron Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative Gold Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative Diamond Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative Redstone Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative Emerald Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative Lapis Lazuli Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative Quartz Ore Decorative Blocks - Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative Jack o' Lantern Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Used mostly for lighting, decoration (also remove the requirement for a block below to be present to be able to place, highly annoying) Book Case Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Mostly used for decoration Coal Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative Iron Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative Diamond Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative Gold Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative Emerald Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative Lapis Block Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Decorative (Wet) Sponge Block Miscellaneous and/or Decorative Blocks Building Blocks Who builds with these... really? Take a close look at the table below and decide which to change, hopefully most of them because they make sense, some of the bottom few are possibly more optional, but especially most of the top ones are highly recommended to change. It is sometimes a hassle to find an item quickly because of this. Most of the times, the search function is preferred cause of this.
        Hide
        CDES5 (Inactive) added a comment - - edited

        Can somebody decide which of the above list would be Applicable, if any?

        Show
        CDES5 (Inactive) added a comment - - edited Can somebody decide which of the above list would be Applicable, if any?
        Hide
        [Mod] FVbico (Steven Verberne) added a comment -

        The above list is more a change suggestion then the bug that got fixed.

        The bug that got fixed was about mending/unbreaking books only appearing in tools when they can be applied to the items from combat too, which can be considered a bug.
        The list is a suggestion of changing where blocks/items are listed correct, but should be changed according to Melvin Schop as they make less sense. That is a feature suggestion. As they are listed correctly and don't cause confusion (unlike the enchanted books).

        Show
        [Mod] FVbico (Steven Verberne) added a comment - The above list is more a change suggestion then the bug that got fixed. The bug that got fixed was about mending/unbreaking books only appearing in tools when they can be applied to the items from combat too, which can be considered a bug. The list is a suggestion of changing where blocks/items are listed correct, but should be changed according to Melvin Schop as they make less sense. That is a feature suggestion. As they are listed correctly and don't cause confusion (unlike the enchanted books).
        Show
        CDES5 (Inactive) added a comment - [Mod] FVbico (Steven Verberne) Thanks Melvin Schop Suggest it on reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/
        Hide
        Melvin Schop added a comment -

        @FVbico
        You could compare these two:

        • Enchantment 1 and 2 can be applied to items in tab A, but also items in tab B.
        • Brewing Ingredient 3 and 4 can be applied to items in tab C, but also applied to items in tab D

        One could think/get confused by the placement of the enchanted books and think these enchantments only work for A, but also work for B.
        On the other hand one could think/get confused by the placement of a food candidate in the brewing section or a brewing candidate in the materials section.

        Ok, I get that the entries towards the bottom of the table become less applicable to above strategy, but may considering consistency be a good recommendation.

        But for simplicity sake: https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/comments/5bw3d6/inconsistency_with_items_in_creative_tabs/

        Show
        Melvin Schop added a comment - @FVbico You could compare these two: Enchantment 1 and 2 can be applied to items in tab A, but also items in tab B. Brewing Ingredient 3 and 4 can be applied to items in tab C, but also applied to items in tab D One could think/get confused by the placement of the enchanted books and think these enchantments only work for A, but also work for B. On the other hand one could think/get confused by the placement of a food candidate in the brewing section or a brewing candidate in the materials section. Ok, I get that the entries towards the bottom of the table become less applicable to above strategy, but may considering consistency be a good recommendation. But for simplicity sake: https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/comments/5bw3d6/inconsistency_with_items_in_creative_tabs/

          People

          • Assignee:
            [Mojang] ProfMobius (Thomas Guimbretiere)
            Reporter:
            [Helper] Marcono1234
          • Votes:
            3 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

            Dates

            • Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:
              CHK: